With the new NBA season starting in just six days, here’s a look at my preseason rankings for the 2012-13 season. Here’s the article covering the lower half of the NBA and here’s the article on the league’s top 15 teams.
For the latest news and analysis on all the action of NBA free agency over the last few days, check out my article via Reup Sports. Today’s post includes Jeremy Lin heading to Houston, Phoenix picking up Luis Scola, the ongoing battle for Nicolas Batum and more!
The Indiana Pacers eliminated the Orlando Magic with a 105-87 win at home in Game 5 last night to advance to the second round of the playoffs. A rocking crowd in the biggest basketball state in the country was there to cheer Indiana on to their first playoff series victory since 2005. The Pacers will now face the winner of the Miami Heat and the New York Knicks in the next round.
Danny Granger led the way for a playoff victory-deprived franchise, finishing with 25 points. Roy Hibbert didn’t have an exceptional game, but luckily for the Pacers, neither did Glen Davis, who had just 15 points and eight rebounds after being the Magic’s best offensive option through the first four games. George Hill and David West both reached double digits in scoring, but it was Darren Collison who ensured the Magic went home empty-handed, scoring 15 of his 19 points in the fourth quarter to turn Indiana’s two point deficit after three quarters into a rout. The Pacers outscored Orlando 36-16 in the fourth quarter and ran away with the game despite Jameer Nelson hitting five 3-pointers and leading the Magic with 27 points.
For Orlando, Glen Davis’ mediocre game really hurt their chances of extending the series, but the majority of these games could have been much closer had Ryan Anderson shown up. Anderson only scored 14 points in Game 4 and averaged just 8.5 ppg for the series on a team with no Dwight Howard and struggling perimeter shooters. The Magic were also hurt by Jason Richardson and Hedo Turkoglu, who didn’t take many shots and missed the majority of them. Orlando surprised everyone with their Game 1 win in Indiana, but after getting that one victory to prove the world wrong and let everyone know they could play without Dwight Howard, they came back down to earth when the Pacers actually showed up for the next four games and revealed who the better team was. The battle between Dwight Howard and Stan Van Gundy over who will stay will likely be decided over the course of the next few months in the offseason, but Orlando had better hope they pick Superman. As good as Van Gundy is, he’s not more valuable than their superstar, which became clear after watching this series against a Pacers team that hasn’t exactly played lights out yet. While it’s unfortunate to suggest Orlando needs to pick their spoiled superstar over an extremely effective coach, the fact is that Van Gundy couldn’t elevate this team to the next level. Dwight Howard can. And if they do get rid of Howard, they’d better be sure to get another game changer who can lift this below-average squad back into playoff contention.
From Indiana’s side of things, they had pretty balanced scoring and really enjoyed the boost off the bench they got from Collison. They face a tough matchup in the second round, most likely against LeBron James and the Miami Heat. If the Knicks miraculously come back and take the series from Miami, Indiana has a much better shot of advancing, provided they limit Carmelo Anthony. Tyson Chandler will likely outplay Roy Hibbert but if David West can frustrate Amare Stoudemire, the Pacers have a better overall team. However, Miami will most likely advance, meaning the Pacers will have to do a few things to be competitive. Danny Granger will have to play lights out offensively and help with the boards. Paul George will have to find a way to use his length to bother LeBron while still contributing on the offensive end. George Hill and Darren Collison will have to keep up their recent level of production and demolish Miami’s guards. And Roy Hibbert will finally have to exploit his opponent’s lack of size to give his side some sort of advantage down low. David West and Chris Bosh will be a key matchup, but if Hibbert can dominate Miami’s bigs, the Pacers have a chance of competing with the Heat. The Pacers would also benefit from their bench outscoring Miami’s. In their series with New York, the Heat have gotten a small advantage from their bench and supporting cast with guys like Mario Chalmers, Shane Battier and Mike Miller hitting a few 3-pointers. This can’t happen to Indiana if they want to shock the world by knocking LeBron James out of the playoffs.
The Pacers survived a late Orlando rally and escaped Game 4 with a 101-99 victory in overtime to take a 3-1 lead on the series. Indiana made up for an embarrassing home loss to the Magic in their playoff opener by winning three straight, including both games in Orlando. The series now shifts back to Indiana and it looks like the Pacers will advance to the second round after edging Glen Davis and Jason Richardson in Game 4.
Although he missed a shot at the buzzer to send the game to double overtime, Glen Davis played another phenomenal game and somehow outperformed Roy Hibbert again, finishing with 24 points and 11 rebounds (compared to Hibbert’s 14 points and 11 rebounds). But even with Hibbert fouling out and Jason Richardson and the rest of Orlando’s perimeter guards hitting shots, the Magic were unable to get the win after erasing a 19-point deficit that the Pacers had built up with just over eight minutes to play. The Magic benefitted from much better outside shooting from Jason Richardson, who ended the night with 25 points, along with Hedo Turkoglu, who shot 50 percent. In fact, every one of Orlando’s starters finished in double digits, even though Jameer Nelson and Ryan Anderson struggled with their shooting. J.J. Reddick had 10 points, including a big 3-pointer late in regulation to tie the game up.
The Pacers built up a sizable third quarter advantage because of David West’s standout performance, leading Indiana with 26 points and 12 rebounds. Danny Granger fulfilled his role as a predominant scorer, finishing with 21 points and seven rebounds, but it was George Hill who ended up being the hero after scoring 11 of his 12 points in the fourth quarter and overtime to hold off Orlando’s desperate run. Hill hit two free throws with 2.2 seconds left to put his team ahead in overtime, which was followed by Glen Davis’ last-second attempt to tie the game and send it to double overtime. And although Paul George only scored two points, his good defense on Davis’ last second shot helped secure Indiana’s Game 4 victory since Roy Hibbert had fouled out.
With the series heading back to Indiana for a decisive Game 5, as long as the Pacers take care of business, they should finish the Magic off. Despite their success in Orlando, they want to finish this series at home and as quickly as possible. Unless the Magic have a stellar shooting night and Ryan Anderson actually shows up to play, the Pacers should run away with this one. Credit Stan Van Gundy and the Magic for competing for the majority of this series, but without Dwight Howard, they’re not a threatening playoff opponent. The Pacers will need to play much better if they advance (which is pretty much a guarantee at this point), but for now, as long as they take care of business at home, they will get a chance to rest before they take on the Heat in round 2 (unless the Knicks defy NBA history and miraculously come back from a 3-0 deficit).
I’ve been pretty hard on Roy Hibbert so far in the Pacers-Magic series because of his inability to dominate Glen Davis and the Orlando frontcourt despite having a five-inch advantage on his opposition. But Hibbert finally came to life in Game 3 and the Pacers cruised to a 97-74 victory on the road. Coincidence? I think not.
After a shocking and all-around ugly loss at home in their playoff opener, Indiana desperately needed to regroup for Game 2. Danny Granger disappeared when his team needed his leadership the most and shot the ball poorly. Hibbert got a huge number of blocks and rebounded well, but he was still outplayed by Glen Davis. And to top it all off, the Pacers bench was nowhere to be found. But in Game 2, they played a much more cohesive and focused game to tie the series up before heading to Orlando. But before Game 3, the one piece of the puzzle that was still missing that prevented this series from being a massacre was Roy Hibbert. And after his 18-point, 10-rebound Game 3 performance, it’s safe to say the Pacers could finally be back on track.
Danny Granger is the alpha dog for this team and Glen Davis is still finding ways to score, but as long as Hibbert continues to rebound and put points on the scoreboard consistently, he should be able to at least balance Davis out. There’s no reason for Glen Davis to have outplayed Hibbert offensively in this series so far, but as long as Hibbert handles the defensive end by rebounding, contesting shots and possibly limiting Davis’ scoring, he’ll have done his job to help Indiana advance past this weaker Orlando team. Paul George and George Hill have been playing better and are consistently scoring, Danny Granger will continue to rack up points as long as he keeps shooting and even Darren Collison reached double figures in Game 3. So as long as Roy Hibbert holds up his end of the bargain by showing up every night (which really isn’t too much to ask considering the size advantage he has on Orlando’s back line), the Pacers should win this series in five games, six at the most.
On the Orlando side of things, Roy Hibbert’s Game 3 performance is pretty much a playoff death sentence. The Magic’s perimeter shooters (Jason Richardson and Hedo Turkoglu) haven’t been able to get anything going since Game 1, Ryan Anderson has tremendously struggled shooting the ball and Jameer Nelson is scoring, but not consistently enough to be a real threat. J.J. Reddick has done well off the bench, but considering their starters’ inability to score outside of Glen Davis, this Magic team that had so much to play for in Game 1 is in serious trouble, even with Game 4 in Orlando tomorrow. Danny Granger will get his 20+ points per game, Paul George and George Hill are on the uprise and David West is a threat to have a good scoring night every game, which is why the Pacers have taken a 2-1 lead on the series. But if Roy Hibbert can lend his offensive talent to his defensive work so far, there is no possible way for Orlando to win this series.
Derrick Rose’s ACL tear and Miami’s blowout on the Knicks were big headlines today, but the Indiana Pacers losing Game 1 at home to the Howard-less Magic should make its own major headlines. I predicted the Pacers would sweep, but Stan Van Gundy and the Magic had other plans. After listening to how guaranteed Indiana’s victory was over the past few days, it’s no surprise Orlando came out fired up. They’ve had a tumultuous season dealing with Dwight Howard’s melodrama and the disunity between him and their coach, but with Howard out, this team has galvanized and now play for each other. Which is probably a big reason why they rallied from a seven-point deficit in the fourth quarter to win 81-77.
But the biggest reason the Magic won is that the Pacers looked like they took this game, and possibly even the whole series, for granted. Indiana was outscored 11-0 in the game’s final minutes and they blew their lead and the game. Nobody could hit a shot, the offense went stagnant and they left shooters like Jason Richardson wide open. But worst of all was Danny Granger completely falling apart. I picked Granger as a top player to watch in the playoffs this year as he became the driving force behind a hot Pacers squad. But when his team needed him most, he not only disappeared, he actually made them worse. He couldn’t get shots close to the rim to go, he missed two critical free throws, he had two terrible turnovers at the worst possible times (a backcourt violation and a travel with the game on the line) and none of this would have been completely terrible if he didn’t look completely timid and indecisive the whole time. Granger turned into a deer in the headlights during the entire fourth quarter, especially when Orlando started to make its run.
The Pacers need Granger to score more than 17 points a game, especially when Leandro Barbosa and Roy Hibbert score a combined 11 points. Hibbert has a ridiculous size advantage on Glen Davis and Ryan Anderson, so scoring 8 points is absolutely pathetic, especially when you throw in the fact that Davis pushed him around all game and the Pacers barely won the rebound battle, 35-34. Hibbert absolutely needs to regroup and come out with a vengeance in Game 2, regardless of his 9 blocks. In fact, David West is the only player on the Pacers who looked okay, but he disappeared down the stretch too. Paul George missed critical wide open 3-pointers down the stretch and George Hill didn’t have much of an impact after looking so impressive when he was moved into the starting lineup. But even with everyone else disappearing, the majority of the blame should still be placed on Danny Granger for this awful performance. Until Granger learns how to take control and be a crunch-time player in close games, the Pacers will never be the dark horse in the East they could be.
Granted, the Magic did have to play exceptionally well to get the win. Jason Richardson hit five 3-pointers, which doesn’t happen every day. The entire Pacers team had to completely collapse and miss all of their shots over the last few minutes for Orlando to have a chance to come back. And while Orlando’s heart in playing for each other and for their coach to defy everyone’s expectations is inspiring, I can’t say with certainty that this team can play at this level over the course of a seven-game series. The Pacers shot 34.5 percent from the floor and finished with 77 points. The Magic only scored 81 points. This was Indiana’s game to lose and they lost it in extremely underwhelming fashion. But I don’t think any of these things will happen again. So even though my prediction that the Pacers would sweep looks pretty bad right now, I’m still picking Indiana to win the series in 5 or 6 games. But they’re definitely on upset alert right now.
Dwight Howard’s year started off and for awhile, it looked like it would be a memorable one. Superman had the Magic at the third spot in the East despite carrying a lackluster supporting cast night in and night out. But Howard’s potential MVP season went downhill pretty quick and will forever be scarred in history by a season-long drama that culminated with yesterday’s announcement that he will miss the remainder of the regular season and the entire playoffs for the Magic. The herniated disk in Howard’s back will require surgery and sideline him from contact drills for four months, meaning he’ll be back next season in full health. But after a tumultuous season full of flip-flopping, behind-the-scenes moves, rumors and apparent backstabbing, should Orlando even want him back?
Dwight Howard put his city through hell this season, but Orlando’s been in an uncomfortable position ever since Howard announced he was unhappy there with Stan Van Gundy. Then management started catering to his every whim in order to appease their spoiled but lovable superstar. They brought in Glen Davis and Gilbert Arenas last year to make him happy, shipping off the now-valuable Brandon Bass to Boston. They most likely bent over backwards before the trade deadline this year to try and bring someone else in to appease Superman. They allegedly told him he’d have managerial powers beyond that of a player, effectively being able to decide the fate of both Van Gundy and GM Otis Smith at the end of the season. Ever since Howard made his discontent and desire to be traded known to the public, Magic management has has done everything but appoint him as head coach and GM in order to get him to stay. Which is still not guaranteed. Enough is enough.
Now I’m not one of those who immediately jumped on the “Blame Howard!” bandwagon when the Magic’s season first started to take a turn for the worse. I didn’t think he was faking his injury or using it as a form of protest after Van Gundy publicly threw him under the bus. Yesterday’s report describing the severity of his injury should prove those rumors to be false. I still don’t know for sure whether or not Howard has to power to decide the fate of Orlando’s head coach and GM. And I understand Howard’s frustration with his team and his coach. If you were a once-in-a-lifetime superstar, would you want to play for the sarcastic Van Gundy surrounded by a bunch of role players who most likely wouldn’t even start for some of the better teams in the league? J.J. Reddick, Jameer Nelson, Hedo Turkoglu, Jason Richardson and even Ryan Anderson are all quality role players and outside shooters at times, but those aren’t the players you build a championship team around. So everyone should ease up off of Dwight Howard a little bit. But it’s just a bit, and that bit ends there.
What we’ve seen from Howard this season has been downright despicable at times. This isn’t the kind of behavior you want to see out of any player on your team, let alone your franchise star. Howard has vehemently denied his involvement in management, he’s denied that he wants Van Gundy gone, he’s denied that he quit on his team and he’s denied that his injury was just an excuse to spite his coach and his teams with all the rumors swirling around him. But Howard is guilty of leaving an entire organization and fan base hanging. He is guilty of flaking back and forth between staying and leaving on the day of the trade deadline. He may be guilty of trying to usurp his head coach who helped develop him into the defensive juggernaut he has become. And while his performance on the court says otherwise, his off-the-court actions, “roll the dice” comments and overall lack of commitment to the city that’s given him so much is just as good as quitting on his team, his fans, his coach and his city. Howard doesn’t understand that he can put up 30 points and 20 rebounds every night for his team, but it won’t make him a team player or a franchise star worth remembering if he’s doing it while looking into where he can play next season.
I think there are a lot of people to blame in this season of melodrama between Dwight Howard and Van Gundy. Howard shouldn’t be orchestrating these managerial moves behind closed doors if he is, just like Van Gundy shouldn’t have said what he said to throw his star player under the bus. You can say all you want about how “that’s just how Van Gundy is” and how he just wants everything to be out in the open, but there are some things you should keep within the family. Telling reporters that Superman wanted him gone was a huge mistake that broke this story open again.
When reports surfaced Thursday morning that Howard wouldn’t play anymore for Stan Van Gundy, I didn’t know what to think. I hesitated on writing about it or passing out judgement until the full story was revealed, and thankfully, Howard furiously denied the latest rumors again and the real report that he required season-ending surgery on his back came out. Never mind the fact that his back got a lot worse because he played through the injury, which happened after people questioned his dedication to his team and the game with that mailed-in performance (the day Van Gundy called him out). Never mind that before all the trade deadline drama and Van Gundy’s foolish mistake, the Magic were playing pretty well behind a terrific season from Howard that deserved MVP consideration. I think that Howard tarnished his legacy in both Orlando and the NBA this season. Some of what ruined his reputation is fair and he should bare the blame for the things he did wrong, but there are some things that Van Gundy and Orlando’s management should have handled better that are unfairly placed on Superman. It will be interesting to see where Van Gundy and Howard end up next season, but for now, blame Dwight for what Dwight did and don’t buy into the rumors until the full story is unveiled. Because things are way too political and deceptive down in Orlando right now to know fact from fiction. Orlando fans should want Dwight Howard back, even if he’s on thin ice. Given the choice between Howard and Van Gundy, they’d be foolish not to pick Howard. But one thing is for sure: lf Dwight Howard is in an Orlando Magic uniform next year, he’s going to have to bust his ass to move up from Clark Kent to Superman again.
If you follow the NBA at all, you’ve probably read about how Chris Mullin’s special night of retiring his jersey was ruined by Golden State fans booing Warriors owner Joe Lacob. Even though you feel bad for Mullin, you’ve probably seen the YouTube video a few times and laughed your ass off while watching a flustered Lacob look for support and an irate Rick Barry scold the audience. At first, I was disgusted with these Warriors fans, booing and ruining what should have been a memorable and happy night not just for Chris Mullin but for the franchise and its ever-supportive fans. But then I realized that Golden State fans have every reason to be upset.
Bill Simmons, my favorite basketball writer, lays out the history of the Warriors franchise in a lengthy article detailing how management has brought some of the best fans in the NBA to their knees. A few awful facts stuck out in reading his article about the Warriors over the past 35 years: 1) They’ve missed the playoffs 29 times in 35 years 2) They haven’t had an NBA All-Star since 1997 3) Despite the Warriors’ awful losing records, they’ve had 22 top-14 picks since 1985 and 4) They’ve given away Chris Webber, Jason Richardson, Baron Davis, Antawn Jamison, Gilbert Arenas as well as coaches Rick Adelman, George Karl and Gregg Popovich.
YIKES. If you’re a diehard Warriors fans (and there really is no other kind of Warriors fan), those last four sentences should break your heart. And after all that the franchise has been through, Warrior fans are still some of the best in the NBA. Everyone saw how riled up Golden State’s fanbase can get when they actually have something to cheer about, evidenced by the Warriors’ improbable playoff run as the eight seed in 2007, knocking off the Dallas Mavericks in six games. Baron Davis, Jason Richardson, Stephen Jackson and Matt Barnes almost led them past the Utah Jazz in the second round, and even if they were eliminated, the Warriors had reason to stand behind their slogan of “We Believe!” (while also giving us Davis’ wicked dunk over Andrei Kirilenko). But then poor management kicked in, players were shipped off and the Warriors have been reeling ever since (again). Until recently, it was starting to become the era of Monta Ellis, Stephen Curry and David Lee.
Even if the team wasn’t going to contend, Ellis gave fans something to cheer about. The Warriors had a young and talented core to build around for the future, even if the present could have been better. Mark Jackson was brought on as head coach and it looked like the franchise might return to its 2007-playoff-run glory. But Jackson hasn’t shaped up to be the coach fans prayed for, Curry has been plagued with ankle injuries and the last straw came in the form of the Monta Ellis trade.
I initially defended this trade for Golden State, noting that the Warriors weren’t going to contend anyway, so there really wasn’t much of a problem gearing up for next year by getting rid of a guard (who isn’t as efficient as he should be) for an injured Andrew Bogut and a declining but still decent Richard Jefferson. But I didn’t stop and think about what Ellis meant to Warriors fans. I didn’t recall Golden State’s terrible history over the past 35 years. I failed to take into account the fact that Warriors fans are some of the most passionate in the NBA, and therefore have no reason to be satisfied with tanking this year in order to improve next season. So for Warriors fans, this trade sent their one glimmer of hope and excitement away for an big man with a history of injuries in addition to an old guy with a cap-space-killing contract.
So unfortunately for Joe Lacob, Chris Mullin, and anyone who’s uncomfortable with awkward situations, I have to applaud the Golden State fanbase for booing their owner during that halftime ceremony. It was high time fans made their discontent be known. I can understand his intentions to look at the big picture and improve for next year, but for an impatient fan, a move like trading Ellis is enraging. Fans should try and have hope for the future and feel some shame in blemishing Mullin’s ceremony. But even though Chris Mullin deserved better on his special night, it’s only fair to equally understand that Golden State Warriors fans have deserved better for 35 years.
With the trade deadline rapidly approaching, talks of the Magic dealing Dwight Howard have all but died down and the general consensus is that Superman will spend the remainder of the season in Orlando. Howard made his intentions of leaving clear a long time ago, but it looks like the Magic are going to take their chances on trying to land a big piece to lure him into staying around a little longer. They take this risk with the knowledge that if they fail, Dwight is free to leave after the season is over and they will receive nothing in return for his departure. Their faith that he will stay either out of loyalty to the city or because they believe they can attract big names is inspiring, but even with Howard, the Magic have seemed to be extremely unpredictable this season.
What’s funny about all of this is that in actuality, the Magic are currently third in the Eastern Conference standings at 25-15. Dwight Howard’s been a monster in the paint, putting up MVP-numbers of 20.7 points, 15 rebounds, 2 blocks and 1.5 steals per game, leading his team in all four of these categories. Even the NBA All-Star game, which brings in a considerable amount of attention and general good feelings, was in Orlando this year. So why does Superman need to leave? And why do the Magic look so dysfunctional despite their status in the East?
First of all, the current state of the East should be addressed. Atlanta, Indiana and Philadelphia are behind right now, but only because they have played less games. Although the Pacers and Sixers are currently suffering losing streaks, they have shown for the majority of the season that they can win and you can be guaranteed they’ll start climbing back up the standings soon. These three teams will soon deflate the Magic’s seemingly impressive standing in the East, which brings up another problem: what’s wrong with the Orlando Magic.
The Magic have a wealth of problems to deal with. Jameer Nelson’s lackluster season is a big one. Orlando’s lack of a bench beyond JJ Reddick is another. A significant drop in Glen Davis’ production from last year with the Celtics, which is a huge contributor to the team’s lack of a bench, represents another unspoken problem. Jason Richardson and Hedo Turkoglu’s inconsistent 3-point shooting and all-around offensive presence compounds the Magic’s troubles even further (J-Rich’s age and injuries certainly don’t help). But the biggest problem the Magic face might come as a surprise. Because of the lack of a great supporting cast around Dwight Howard, the city of Orlando is starting to realize that the biggest reason for the Magic’s problems is Superman himself.
On paper, that statement doesn’t make much sense. Howard is the most coveted big man in the league for a reason. He’s putting up MVP-numbers this season and is the biggest factor in the Orlando Magic winning games. On a team where Ryan Anderson is the only other bright spot, the majority of the Magic’s success should be attributed to Dwight Howard. But although this is all true, Superman is still the reason for Orlando’s losses and problems. We can point to Nelson and J-Rich not contributing enough, but it must be pretty difficult to focus on your job when your star player and team rock is talking about where he could see himself playing every week. Howard opening his mouth about playing in New Jersey or Chicago or L.A. or Golden State has damaged this team’s chemistry. Yes, the Magic are winning ballgames. Yes, Dwight Howard has stated over and over again that until that trading day comes, he’s giving everything he’s got to the city of Orlando. And yes, Howard has elevated his play to prove that he means what he says. But can anyone really be fooled into thinking that Superman and the rest of his teammates are of sound mind or have any chance at building team chemistry with all this off-court turmoil?
The smartest thing would have been to accept that it’s time to rebuild, find a quality trade for Howard (a decent big man and a dynamic guard/forward would have been ideal) and move on. There were talks of dealing Howard to the Lakers, but the Magic would have been slightly downgrading at the center position, and even if they got both Pau Gasol and Andrew Bynum, they would still be hurting for better guards/forwards. And any chances of Dwight joining Deron Williams in New Jersey faded as the already-downgrade prospect Brook Lopez continues to struggle with injury problems.
So instead, the Magic switched to trying to keep Howard interested in staying in Orlando by looking at Monta Ellis in Golden State. But the Warriors aren’t interested in what the Magic have to offer (what team should be?), so the only way Ellis is coming to Orlando is if Superman himself ships off for Golden State. Now the Magic are in real trouble, because without the ability to attract any big names, along with several bad losses on the season (a 31-point loss to the Celtics, a 26-point loss to the Hornets and Tuesday’s 16-point loss to the five-win Charlotte Bobcats), Dwight Howard most likely feels like it’s time to move on. The only thing Orlando has going for it in hoping that Dwight Howard resigns with the Magic is that their pure loyalty and love for him persuades him to stick around.
Superman has had an immediate and substantial impact on his team since he first donned an Orlando Magic uniform. The Magic went to the Finals and have been competitive in the Eastern Conference playoffs for the past few years, but have come up just short every time. And every time Dwight Howard takes the court and leads the Magic to a win, I’m reminded of the climactic scene of Superman Returns, where Superman carries a giant growing mass of land and kryptonite away from the citizens of Metropolis, flying higher and higher into the sky where he launches it into space before plummeting to the ground as the kyptonite finally takes its toll. Dwight Howard’s superhuman efforts carry this team, but the kryptonite that is the Orlando Magic has taken its toll and it might not be long before Superman falls right into another city.
The 2012 Dunk Contest was absolutely terrible this year. In years past, the Dunk Contest had a history of being the most significant event of All-Star Weekend other than the All-Star game itself, but recently it has gone downhill until this year it reached an all-time low. In 2012, the Dunk Contest might have been the worst event of the entire weekend (and that’s saying something). The big names weren’t there, the dunks were mediocre at best and the entire show just seemed like a huge flop. How has an entertaining event like this that provided us with signature dunks from the likes of Dominique Wilkins, Michael Jordan, Vince Carter and Jason Richardson sunk so low?
There were three big problems with this year’s Slam Dunk Contest. The dunkers and their dunks were the first problem. Nothing against Paul George, Jeremy Evans, Chase Budinger and Derrick Williams, but where are the big name dunkers? Even though he competed last year and did an overrated theatrical dunk, Blake Griffin also had the best dunk of the year so far, why isn’t he being persuaded (or forced if necessary) to participate? How about LeBron James, one of the most athletic guys in the game who can jump entirely over another human being? Or even John Wall, who threw down a behind-the-back dunk in the rising stars game? The Dunk Contest has been so entertaining in the past because it got the most electrifying dunkers in the game to compete. Paul George and Jeremy Evans had their moments, but other than that there were few memorable dunks.
The second problem with the Dunk Contest, which is increasingly becoming a bigger trend, is the theatricality. What made Dunk Contests in the past so awesome was that it emphasized creativity, but at the end of the day it was really about the dunks. The theatricality of the Dunk Contest has completely overshadowed the sole purpose of the night: athletic and inventive dunks that shock and amaze the audience. Dressing up like Superman (while throwing the ball at the basket, not actually dunking it), jumping over the shortest part of a Kia, and other similar gimmicks have blinded people to the point that now the audience doesn’t even bat an eyelash at the truly difficult dunks. Paul George’s dunk in the dark was cool and unique, but was the dunk itself really that great? Meanwhile Derrick Williams takes a page out of Blake Griffin’s book and dunks over a motorcycle, completely abandoning originality AND any dunking skill (it took him multiple tries) he might possess for the sake of putting a shiny motorcycle on the court. Chase Budinger didn’t try to distract fans with theatricality, but his complete lack of originality kept him out of the race. Fortunately, Jeremy Evans’ impressive feat of dunking two balls at once was not overlooked and he rightfully ended up winning (although Paul George’s dunk over Roy Hibbert was really impressive. And don’t talk to me about him putting his hand on Hibbert’s shoulder to “boost” himself. You try dunking cleanly and completely over a 7-footer and then talk to me). Theatricality has taken the emphasis off of the dunks themselves and turned the Dunk Contest into a circus show.
The final problem was minor and easily fixable, but definitely prevalent this year more than most. The TNT commentators absolutely killed the atmosphere of the whole event. The Dunk Contest thrives on the noise of the crowd, the energy of the arena and the burst of exclamation that erupts when somebody throws one down. It’s really hard for people to get into that kind of mindset when Kenny Smith is talking to the dunkers and interviewing them right before they’re about to do their thing. I love the TNT guys; Kenny Smith, Charles Barkley, Ernie Johnson, Shaq, Reggie Miller and Mike Fratello are all great because they know the game and are entertaining to watch. But they’re commentators, not circus ringleaders. I know the whole weekend is about the fun and festive atmosphere and that they’re trying to be a part of that, but their efforts to get the crowd involved are having the exact opposite effect when they take on a constant host/interviewer role. Lose the mics on the court and give your commentary after the dunks. The people don’t need a play-by-play and interview every time something significant happens.
If the NBA fixes these three problems, the Dunk Contest might go back to its glory days in the 90s and early 2000s. But until then, we’re going to keep sitting through an hour of mediocre entertainment with small-time dunkers and constant talking. Please, NBA. Bring back to the glory days.